Craft vs. Art
There is a big difference between someone who is a craftsman, and one who is an artist. And I feel that there is a big difference between the works produced by craftsmen as opposed to artists. Some "craftsmen" call themselves artists. That they "produce" art. Yes. That is true, to an extent. But for me, true "art" comes from another place in the psyche. It is not just a clever assemblage of items that ends up appearing as a beautiful object, be it a painting, sculpture, novel, or musical composition, created for a specific commercial purpose. For it to be art, it must come to be by not rationallity, or practicality, or for any other purpose other than to just be an expression of the spirit, channeled through the human mind and body. It contains the aspects of technique, skills, learned entities, that are required for the meduim chosen, but they are just the vehicle for the expression. They are not the "art". Therefore, for a singer, or musician, who has not composed the work they are singing, to call themselves an artist, I feel is not the right term. They are craftsmen, or artisans, carrying on the expression of the artistry created by the composer, who is the true artist, through "stewardship". Taking care to keep the works of sonic art alive in the present day. Many composers are, and were, great craftsmen and stewards, but not artists.

22 Comments:
At first, the things of the lower caste of "art" may seem simple to create in that it comes from a place un-attached to realities or restrictions or disciplined rules. Almost any child can create something with a creative original aspect. It requires no training to want to create. It just comes from within us and can appear out of no-where. As if effortlessly and in-intelligibly made. Naive is the word.
But then one examines and ponders what one has just created, and then looks back on how one created it. How ? did you do it. It is the how that is the craft. One begins to learn the chemistry, mechanics, techniques, learns about how separate components or techniques work and relate to one-another. Craft. How the craft makes the art possible. Then the craft takes on a bigger importance because there is so much to learn how to do. One can get caught up in the specifics of the craft and begin to feel that by just accurately manipulating the components of the craft, that art is the result. Not true. It is more like mimicry. Following a formula that produces a pretty close approximation of art.
Once one learns the craft associated with the art, then you basically start from square one again and see if that now, with a broader knowledge of the things that are the components of the medium, if one can channel something truly original using one's own spirit and knowledge as the catalyst that transforms the pure un-directed inspiration to create, into something tangible. Or by use of variation on an existing idea, see if the concept of the original variation idea can carry the spirit of pure original creativity. The variation becomes the art. Mozart. Beethoven. Etc. Endless variations on an existing concept that in some cases transends into art by it's shear beauty and force. Not just an attractive assemblage.
But as time goes by, one notices that the opportunities for significant enough variation are diminishing to the point that a breakaway must occur in order for new inspiration to take place in more original ways. This is the area where art comes to the fore, because one is no longer looking at the existing formulas to mimic or vary, but one is attempting to make a truly original statement. Then one must go back full circle to the childlike state where there are less inhibitors present to block or taint the process of channeling the pure spirit of original creativity.
And start all over again with the learning and discovery process using the new territory to expand into. That is where true art is created. Most everything else tends to evolve, or de-volve, into a mimicery or un-intentional parody of itself. Then it is not art. It is a replicated product that only looks (or sounds) like art.
Wynton Marsalis related a story about a young jazz aspirant that played for some well known and respected jazz master. After playing through a complete number, improved solos, etc., the young man asked the veteran what he thought. The master said " Well played, it's obvious that you have learned your lessons well, excellent and I was entertained,--- but,--- just what are you trying to say?
It's this "what are you trying to say" thing that is where it's at in art. Your music or art has got to say something. Mean something, not just be executed well or sound as good as, or like, artist or composer or performer X-Y-Z. Not just composed well, and entertaining, but, does it really say anything? Anything new?
There are many ways to say 'no' and it is part of the performer's
artistry to pronounce/place it in a certain way to create a certain
effect, in line with the artistic intentions that the performer has with
the line that has been provided.In many cases a dull line may thus
become hugely
impactful/strong/moving/theatrical/over-the-top/comical/what have you.
Many are the cases where a dull work has been turned into a vibrant work
of art because the performing artist injected it with his/her
energy/life force/personality. Many minor works of all the great
operatic schools fit this profile: they require a great performing
artist to come to life.
So yes, performers can be artists too.
The problem is the word "art" itself. Regardless
of how any dictionary defines or fails to define it,
the word itself mostly just serves as a filler word
in sentences. Someone writes a sentence, inserts that
word somewhere in the sentence, and everyone interprets
it differently. It is a useful word as long as one is
just speaking in general terms, but when one tries to
define the difference between craft and art, forget it.
Is a bird's nest craft, art, or nature.
I am not interested in your opinion of the difference,
and I am sure you are not interested in mine. This is
the kind of stupid immature meaningless crap that college
students sit around and talk about for hours. An issue
that can never be resolved, because by its very nature
it is just a matter of opinion.
Don't use words like "art" in conjunction with words
like "craft." You are just going to piss people off,
and show your own immaturity.
"Technique" and "Love" are two other words to add to the
list of stupid English filler words with "art."
All this is just my stupid immature opinion of course,
and that's my point exactly.
Frank.
One way to distinguish craft from art is that in craft, the outcome is more predetermined whereas in art it is more a surprise/revelation due to the artist's individuality.
I would call a singer an artist if, in addition to singing/performing with a keen sense of correctness, precision and accuracy, he/she also sang/performed in such a way as to bring out an unsuspected potential or unexpected possibility in an aria/role.
I would call a singer an 'artist' if, in addition to singing/performing
without losing sight of correctness, precision and accuracy, the singer
brought out unexpected possibility in an aria/role.
But at an even higher level of artistry, I would call a singer an 'artist'
if the singer not only revealed the unsuspected potential of an aria/role
(e.g., Callas' efforts to illuminate the drama of LUCIA), but also released
the unsuspected potential in themselves (e.g., D. Kirsten performing in
FANCIULLA).
However, I think that Rossini would agree with Mr. Black since R. said:
- The good singer should be nothing but an able interpreter of the ideas of
the master, the composer... In short, the composer and the poet are the
only true creators.
The true difference one looks for... is the difference between an
artist and an artisan...
True... you might spend hours in a single day wondering about the two. But in the end, it all depends on a single, irrelevant point of view.
The key is not to define the words and add them to a dictionary of interesting definitions... But to
be able to tell (feel) the difference between an artisan's work and the work of an artist...
it all remains in the concept...
Richard Lo Bianco
no definition of art will ever be accurate...
At the point when one knows so much that one forgets... one makes something unique... with a concept of one's reflection on a portion of life... then...
..one is able to notice the difference between an artisan and an artist...
no definitions...
jazz...
Hi The Art of Singing, I came across your site while doing a search on Sexy Celebrities, popular female sigers, dancers, actresses and models. Though you don't have exactly what I was searching for it still provided quite an interested read. Thanks and keep up the good work!
Hi there The Art of Singing, I was just cruising the blogosphere searching for the latest information on religious art and came across this great blog. Although Craft vs. Art wasn’t quite what I was looking for, it has excellent articles. I see now why I found your page when I was looking for religious art related topics. I’m glad I stop by, keep up the good work.
Hi there The Art of Singing, I was just traveling through looking for some interesting stuff on and I came upon your Blog. I haven’t seen what I was after regarding Craft vs. Art, but I’m going to carry on searching for more information on related stuff. By the way your Blogs great.
Well hello there The Art of Singing, I was just searching for some ideas on religious art when I happened on to your Blog. Although Craft vs. Art isn’t quite what I was looking for, it was for more information on religious art. You’ve still got a great Blog here.
Hi there The Art of Singing, I was just cruising the blogosphere searching for the latest information on poster art and came across this great blog. Although Craft vs. Art wasn’t quite what I was looking for, it has excellent articles. I see now why I found your page when I was looking for poster art related topics. I’m glad I stop by, keep up the good work.
Hi there The Art of Singing, I was just traveling through looking for some interesting stuff on poster art and I came upon your Blog. I haven’t seen what I was after regarding Craft vs. Art, but I’m going to carry on searching for more information on poster art related stuff. By the way your Blogs great.
Well hello there The Art of Singing, I was just searching for some ideas on when I happened on to your Blog. Although Craft vs. Art isn’t quite what I was looking for, it was for more information on . You’ve still got a great Blog here.
Hi there The Art of Singing, I was just cruising the blogosphere searching for the latest information on impressionist art and came across this great blog. Although Craft vs. Art wasn’t quite what I was looking for, it has excellent articles. I see now why I found your page when I was looking for impressionist art related topics. I’m glad I stopped by this is a great Blog, keep up the good work. You are most welcomed to visit my site at impressionist art
Hi there The Art of Singing, I was just traveling through looking for some interesting stuff on abstract art and I came upon your Blog. I haven’t seen what I was after regarding Craft vs. Art, but I’m going to carry on searching for more information on abstract art related stuff. By the way your Blogs great. You are most welcomed to visit my site at abstract art
Hi there The Art of Singing, I was just traveling through looking for some interesting stuff on poster art and I came upon your Blog. I haven’t seen what I was after regarding Craft vs. Art, but I’m going to carry on searching for more information on poster art related stuff. By the way your Blogs great. You are most welcomed to visit my site at poster art
Hi there The Art of Singing, I was just traveling through looking for some interesting stuff on and I came upon your Blog. I haven’t seen what I was after regarding Craft vs. Art, but I’m going to carry on searching for more information on related stuff. By the way your Blogs great. You are most welcomed to visit my site at
Hello The Art of Singing,
After reading your blog "Craft vs. Art", I believe you will find the wages information on my site about Jobs With Best Wages to be very helpful.
To give you an idea of our wide range, some of the recent searches that found our site included ...
Public Address Announcers Wages
Public Relations Specialists Wages
Radio & Television Announcers Wages
Technical Writers Wages
Radio Operators Wages
Reporters & Correspondents Wages
Set & Exhibit Designers Wages
Writers & Authors Wages
Sound Engineering Technicians Wages.
We have hundreds of "must read" articles on wages and careers and many other topics in our Top Career Wages site.
Kind Regards
Emily
Hi The Art of Singing I’ve been looking for impressionist art related blogs and I came across yours on Craft vs. Art during my trawl, so I thought it would be polite to let you know about my visit. I have just recently started a daily news feed on my own site and you are most welcome to come and visit me at impressionist art.
Great blog. I surf the web looking for blogs like
this. Your site was on point and will be back again!
Please take a journey to my plastic surgery texas blog.
Post a Comment
<< Home